Published: · By Benjie · Updated with the November 2026 payouts
Quick Answer

$QQQI pays more, about 15% over the last 12 months versus about 12% for $SPYI. $SPYI is more diversified and has held its share price better. Both are NEOS funds with the same 0.68% fee, the same monthly pay dates and the same tax-friendly setup. And over the time they've both existed, the total return with the cash taken out is almost a tie. So the real question isn't which one is better. It's how much Nasdaq-100 tech risk you want for that extra 3% of yield.

QQQI 12-Mo Yield
~14.9%
SPYI 12-Mo Yield
~12.1%
Fee (Both)
0.68%
Pays
Monthly
Next Ex-Date
Dec 16

🚨 Compare $SPYI and $QQQI Live Next to 130+ Income ETFs

TopDividendETFsPRO gives you advanced filtering, ratings, live yields and price decay for 130+ income ETFs in one screener, so you can line up $SPYI, $QQQI, $JEPQ, $GPIQ and the rest of the option income crowd in seconds. From $12.95/mo, or grab lifetime access.

Try TopDividendETFsPRO →
NEOS S&P 500 High Income vs NEOS Nasdaq-100 High Income

SPYI vs QQQI 2026: Which NEOS Income ETF Is Better?

The two biggest NEOS funds head to head: what each one pays, every payout by year, total return since 2024, what's actually inside them, how they're taxed, and which one I'd rather own.

$14.8BQQQI Net Assets
$12.6BSPYI Net Assets
$0.5838QQQI Nov Payout
$0.5160SPYI Nov Payout
NoPrice Decay (Both)

Same Playbook, Different Index

$SPYI is the NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF, with an inception date of August 29, 2022. $QQQI is the NEOS Nasdaq-100 High Income ETF, which came later, with an inception date of January 29, 2024. Together they hold about $27 billion: $14.8 billion in $QQQI and $12.6 billion in $SPYI as of November 10, 2026.

The strategy is the same in both. The fund owns the stocks in its index, then sells call options on the index itself (SPX for $SPYI, NDX for $QQQI) to generate monthly income. NEOS can also buy calls, which lets the fund keep some upside instead of capping all of it like an old school covered call fund. Both use index options that qualify as Section 1256 contracts, taxed 60% long term and 40% short term, and NEOS says both funds' distributions have been classified as return of capital.

Here's the part most people miss: the yield difference isn't magic. The Nasdaq-100 is more volatile than the S&P 500, and more volatility means fatter option premiums. $QQQI pays more because it's taking more risk. That's the whole trade.

SPYI vs QQQI Side by Side

$SPYI vs $QQQI

NEOS
$SPYI$QQQI
IndexS&P 500Nasdaq-100
InceptionAug 29, 2022Jan 29, 2024
Expense ratio0.68%0.68%
Net assets (Nov 10, 2026)$12.6B$14.8B
Price (Nov 10, 2026 close)$52.21$50.78
Latest payout (Nov 2026)$0.5160$0.5838
Distribution rate (Oct 31)11.43%14.09%
12-month trailing distribution rate (Oct 31)11.84%14.13%
30-day SEC yield (Oct 31)0.48%-0.05%
Yield on our list11.4%14.1%
Price decay on our listNoNo
Payouts so far51 (since Sep 2022)34 (since Feb 2024)

Source: NEOS Investments fund pages (fund details as of November 10, 2026; distribution data as of October 31, 2026); prices from Yahoo Finance; yield and price decay from the live TopDividendETFs.com list. The SEC yield only counts dividends and interest minus expenses, so it misses the option premium that funds the payouts.

What $10,000 Pays in Each

Hypothetical, before taxes, at November 10, 2026 closing prices.

Investment$SPYI per month (latest)$SPYI per year (last 12)$QQQI per month (latest)$QQQI per year (last 12)
$10,000~$99~$1,210~$115~$1,494
$50,000~$494~$6,049~$575~$7,468
$100,000~$988~$12,098~$1,150~$14,936

"Latest" uses the November 2026 payouts ($0.5160 for $SPYI, $0.5838 for $QQQI). "Last 12" uses December 2025 through November 2026 ($6.3166 and $7.5843 per share). Payouts are not guaranteed. Project reinvested income with the DividendProjection.com calculator.

On $100,000 that's roughly a $3,000 a year difference in income. Real money. If you need $1,000 a month, you'd need about $80,000 in $QQQI at the current pace versus about $99,000 in $SPYI. That gap is why $QQQI pulled in more assets than its older sibling in less than three years.

Payouts by Year

Total distributions per share by calendar year, from the NEOS distribution histories.

Year$SPYI total$SPYI avg/month$QQQI total$QQQI avg/month
2026 11 OF 12$5.7850$0.5259$6.9430$0.6312
2025$6.1458$0.5121$7.4435$0.6203
2024$6.1182$0.5099$6.7294 (11 payouts)$0.6118
2023$5.7873$0.4823n/an/a
2022$1.8897 (4 payouts)$0.4724n/an/a

Based on ex-dividend dates. Through the first 11 payouts of 2026, $SPYI is up 3.0% and $QQQI is up 2.1% versus the same months of 2025.

What I like here: both funds have kept the monthly check steady and slowly rising, which is not what you see from most high yield option funds. The lowest $QQQI payout was $0.5309 in April 2025 and the highest was $0.6589 in May 2026. For $SPYI the range since launch is $0.4615 to $0.5564. If you want every single payment, here's the full $QQQI dividend history and the $SPYI dividend history page.

When do $SPYI and $QQQI pay next?

Same day for both. NEOS has published the calendar: the November distribution went ex on November 18, 2026 and pays November 20 ($0.5160 for $SPYI, $0.5838 for $QQQI). December goes ex on December 16 and pays December 18. Own shares by the close on the day before the ex-date. Every date is on the $SPYI dividend dates and $QQQI dividend dates calendars.

📈 See How SPYI and QQQI Rank Against 99 Other Dividend ETFs
Daily-updated yields, AUM, price decay & total returns. 100% free.
View Top 100 ETFs →

The Real Test: Total Return

Yield is only half of it. Here's what I actually look at: share price change plus every distribution. To make it fair, I started both funds on the same day, $QQQI's first close on January 30, 2024, and assumed you spent every check instead of reinvesting.

$10,000 on Jan 30, 2024, cash not reinvested$SPYI$QQQI
Starting price~$48.93~$49.84
Price on Nov 10, 2026$52.21$50.78
Price change+6.7%+1.9%
Distributions collected~$3,483~$4,120
Value of shares~$10,670~$10,189
Total~$14,154 (+42%)~$14,309 (+43%)

Approximate, using Yahoo Finance closing prices and NEOS distribution data (33 payouts each, ex-dates after January 30, 2024). Ignores taxes and trading costs.

A near tie. $QQQI paid you about $640 more in cash. $SPYI kept about $480 more in share value. That's exactly the trade-off you'd expect: more income from the Nasdaq fund, a steadier price from the S&P 500 fund. Neither one shows price decay over this window, which is the thing I care about most in a high income fund.

Timing matters a lot, though. NEOS's own numbers show how fast the lead flips:

NAV total return$SPYI$QQQIS&P 500Nasdaq-100
1 year, as of Sep 30, 202614.62%17.97%15.74%24.00%
1 year, as of Oct 31, 202611.91%7.09%12.11%10.47%
Year to date, as of Oct 31, 202610.37%7.89%11.77%12.98%
October 2026 alone-0.43%-5.91%-0.87%-6.63%

Source: NEOS Investments month-end and quarter-end performance. Total return assumes distributions are reinvested. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

One rough month for tech (the Nasdaq-100 fell 6.63% in October) and $QQQI went from leading by more than 3 points over a year to trailing by almost 5. That's what more tech exposure does. It cuts both ways. Both funds also trail their plain index over time, which is the cost of selling calls. If you want the head to head against $VOO and $QQQ, ETFTotalReturns.com runs that math fund by fund.

What's Actually Inside Each Fund

Top holdings (Nov 11, 2026)$SPYI weight$QQQI weight
Apple ($AAPL)7.79%8.36%
Nvidia ($NVDA)6.28%6.68%
Microsoft ($MSFT)6.06%6.52%
Amazon ($AMZN)4.07%4.81%
Next names in the top 10Alphabet, Broadcom, Meta, Eli Lilly, TeslaAMD, Micron, Tesla, Meta, SpaceX, Walmart

Source: NEOS Investments top holdings, data as of November 11, 2026.

The top four are the same in both funds, just a little heavier in $QQQI. The difference shows up after that. $SPYI's top 10 includes a drugmaker (Eli Lilly), and the rest of the S&P 500 brings in banks, energy, healthcare and industrials. $QQQI is 100 Nasdaq names, so it leans hard into tech, chips and growth, with no banks and very little energy. If you already own a lot of tech, $QQQI doubles down on it. If you want an income fund that looks more like the whole market, that's $SPYI.

Which One I'd Rather Own

Personally, I'd rather own a fund that pays 12% and holds its price than chase 15% and ride every tech selloff. But that's a preference, not a rule. When I was building toward financial freedom, the funds I leaned on were the ones I could hold through a bad month without wanting to sell. Know which one that is for you. And if you want even more frequent checks, WeeklyETFs.com tracks every weekly payer, while MonthlyETFs.com covers the rest of the monthly crowd.

The Risks I'd Want You to Know

For the deeper list, see the biggest risks in $QQQI and what happens to $QQQI's distribution when the price drops.

My Takeaway

$QQQI pays more, about 15% versus 12%, and $SPYI holds its price better. Since $QQQI launched, $10,000 in either one ended up within about $150 of the other with the cash taken out. They share the same fee, the same strategy, the same tax setup and the same pay dates. The only real choice is S&P 500 or Nasdaq-100.

If you want one fund to anchor your monthly income, I lean $SPYI for the diversification. If you want to squeeze more income out of the same dollars and you can handle tech volatility, $QQQI earns its spot. Weighing $QQQI against J.P. Morgan's fund instead? See $JEPQ vs $QQQI. Either way, track the total return, not just the yield. Every NEOS fund is ranked in the top NEOS ETFs of 2026, and the free list on TopDividendETFs.com updates daily. TopDividendETFsPRO lets you filter 130+ income ETFs by price decay, ratings and live yield, and more calculators live on TopDividendTools.com.

Frequently Asked Questions: SPYI vs QQQI

Related Posts

Dividend Dates

SPYI Dividend Dates 2026

Every 2026 $SPYI ex-date and pay date.

Dividend Dates

QQQI Dividend Dates 2026

The full $QQQI calendar for 2026.

Dividend History

QQQI Dividend History

Every $QQQI payout since 2024.

Taxes

Why NEOS ETFs Are Tax Friendly

$SPYI and $QQQI return of capital explained.

Rankings

Top NEOS ETFs 2026

Distribution rates and total returns ranked.

Sister Site

ETFTotalReturns.com

Head to head total return comparisons.

⭐ Find the High Income ETFs That Don't Eat Your Principal

TopDividendETFsPRO is the screener I built for serious income investors: advanced filtering, ratings, live yields and price decay for 130+ income ETFs like $SPYI, $QQQI, $JEPQ and $GPIX. Filter out the funds with price decay and keep the ones that pay you without shrinking.

From $12.95/mo or one-time lifetime access

Unlock TopDividendETFsPRO →

Important Disclaimer

TopDividendETFs.com is published by Dividend Empire LLC for educational and informational purposes only. This is not financial advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Do your own research and consult a licensed financial advisor before investing. $SPYI and $QQQI distribution histories, distribution calendars, fund details, holdings, yields and performance come from NEOS Investments; share prices from Yahoo Finance; yields and price decay from the TopDividendETFs.com list. Data as of November 11, 2026 (prices and fund details as of November 10, 2026; distribution rates and month-end performance as of October 31, 2026; holdings as of November 11, 2026). Past distributions do not guarantee future payments, and income and total return examples are hypothetical and before taxes. Tax treatment varies by investor; consult a tax professional. TopDividendETFs.com is not affiliated with NEOS Investments.